|
It was one of those parties where everyone was talking at once.
In one corner, Lois was talking and waving a sheet of newspaper about. I trell you, she said George and I were both standing on the same sheet of newpaper, and we couldnt touch one another! Thats easy, muttered a voice from somewhere. You just tear it in half! No, replied Lois, it was in one piece. Look, Ill show you how. And she did! How did she do it? A little later the guests were dismayed to find only dry biscuits for supper. I can explain, said the host. Dry biscuits are better than nothing. Nothing is better than chocolate cake. Therefore, dry biscuits are better than chocolate cake! You cant complain! Thats what he thinks. Im not going there again! But what is wrong with the logic? |
Hints and strategies |
HINT 1
Problems like this newspaper puzzler are usually simple! Think about where it might be placed. |
HINT 2
Think about the use of the word nothing. |
SOLUTION
We have two problems to solve here. The newspaper is placed under a closed door with Lois and George on opposite sides of the door. The logic fails because the the word nothing is used in two different senses. In the first statement, nothing means not having anything. In the second, it really manes no thing. |
EXTENSIONS This type of Aha! is really a swindle. Take any two or three easy conundrums, and put them together in a common setting. It is quite easy! |